Michigan State University College of Human Medicine (MSU/CHM)
GMEC Internal Review Protocol for
ACGME Accredited Residency Programs


Approved by the GMEC August, 1997.
Approved as amended, March, 2002
Approved as amended, January, 2005


The ACGME requires regular review of all residency programs to assess their compliance with both the Institutional Requirements and Program Requirements of the relevant ACGME Residency Review Committees. MSU/CHM assures that Internal Reviews will be conducted at the mid-point between RRC visits. MSU/CHM assures that the review will be conducted by the GMEC or a body designated by the GMEC, and will include:

        • Faculty
        • Residents - peer selected residents at each level of the residency will be included
        •Administrators - both within and outside the department in which the residency exists.
        •External reviewers may also be utilized as determined by the GMEC.

MSU/CHM will appraise the following in its Internal Review of residency programs:

        •The extent to which each program has defined, in accordance with the relevant Program Requirements, the specific knowledge, skills and attitudes required to successfully complete the program
        •The extent to which each program has educational experiences for the residents to demonstrate competency in the following areas; patient care skills, medical knowledge, interpersonal and communication skills, professionalism, practice-based learning, and systems-based practice
        •Evidence of the program's use of evaluation tools to ensure that the residents demonstrate competence in each of the six areas listed above
        • Evidence of the development and use of dependable outcome measures by the program for each of the general competencies
        •The effectiveness of each program in implementing a process that links educational outcomes with program improvement

Materials and data to be used in the review process must include:

        •Institutional and program requirements from the Essentials of Accredited Residency Programs.
        •Letters of Accreditation from previous ACGME reviews.
        •Reports from previous internal reviews of the program.
        •Interviews with Program Director, faculty, and residents in the program, and individuals outside the program deemed appropriate by the Committee.
        • Note: The ACGME Outcomes Project is now in Phase II. This requires that Program Directors provide for Internal Reviews documentation that the program provides learning opportunities in all six competency domains
        • In addition, Program Directors must also provide documentation that programs are implementing evaluation processes as needed to obtain accurate resident performance data in all six competency domains (see Attachment A)
        •Finally, Program Directors must provide documentation of aggregate resident performance data.

MSU/CHM will provide documentation of the review including:

        •Description of mechanisms or plans to correct identified deficiencies.
        •Dates on which the GMEC will review the document
        •A succinct summary for each review.




[ Home]  [GMEC]  [Related Links]  [E Mail the Web Master]